NowTHINK!AboutIt

Avoiding Hackneyed...Making Sense

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

“Christian” Is Biblical – “Religion” Not So Much

November 17, 2026 by EnnisP Leave a Comment

The Question Nobody Wants to Answer

Here’s a question worth considering: If the American government were run on Christian terms, like a church — which is, at least, what Christian Nationalists are asking for — whose Christianity would be in charge?

The suggestion, of course, that the government should be Christianized beyond what it is now implies that democracy as we know it, spelled out in the constitution and maintained by various government agencies, is not aligned with Christian principles and can only be improved by becoming more church-like.

Can that really be true?

Is it impossible for an institution to be Christian without becoming like a church? Must the laws of the land match the laws of the church exactly?

Will a Christianized government require everyone to be baptized to be a legitimate citizen and if so, which form of baptism will be instituted: sprinkling, emersion, dipping upside down, or what?

That last question is significant because not even churches agree on a standardized statement of which laws should apply to church and how things should be done. If Christians can’t agree on what practices should be instituted and what beliefs to endorse, how will Christians ever agree on how governments should run?

So the question remains. Is a government supposed to be like a church? Shouldn’t one be distinct from the other? Must citizens be required to abide by church rules? Must the laws of the government match those of the church?

Is that idea found anywhere in the Bible? Even the theocratic government outlined in Exodus through Deuteronomy was far more democratic and less imposing than Christian Nationalism appears to be.

Another good question: Would those ousted from church for transgression now be imprisoned or exiled from the US?

Would it be a law that those who missed church regularly be shunned or treated with disdain? Would these apparent slackers be left out of business deals and opportunities?

That’s how religious communities act toward one another now. How much worse would things become if Christian Nationalism became the rule?

Potential questions are endless and not even the obvious ones have been thoroughly considered. It’s all very worrisome especially when you consider the fact that the Apostles didn’t require new converts to live by the common religious dictums of their day (Acts 15:10-11).

Which Version Of Christianity Reigns

The lack of standardization among Christian religions is a concern.

There are more than 40,000 distinct versions of Christianity at present and the number continues to grow. They disagree with each other on a number of issues: baptism, salvation, church authority, and a dozen other questions that each group considers non-negotiable. So “Christianizing the government” isn’t actually a clear plan. It’s a promise that one faction’s reading of the Bible will be handed the power to write law for everyone else, including other Christians.

What you can be sure of is that the most influential religion will be the biggest or loudest or the one with the most wealth and especially one that has spent years encouraging adherents to aim for and qualify for public office. Yes, I’m talking about the Catholic Church and they qualify in every metric. Seven of our present Supreme Court Justices were raised Catholic.

That should trouble Christians more than anyone. And the reason it doesn’t — the reason “Christian government” sounds to many like a solution rather than a warning — is that we’ve stopped distinguishing between two things that are not the same: Christianity and religion.

That distinction is the core issue in this discussion.

Christianity Is Personal. Religion Is Institutional

Start with the basic claim: Christianity and religion are not synonyms. You can be Christian without being religious, and religious without being Christian. Religion is nothing more than a set of ideas, values and beliefs to which a group adheres. It doesn’t have to be Christian. In fact, two thirds of humanity are associated with non-Christian religious devotions.

Claiming to be religious tells you someone is consistent. Maybe! It says nothing about whether they’re consistently right, or good, or bearable to be around.

Religion is an institution — a system of teachings, practices, and group identity – that people subscribe to and in which they are shaped. There are religious expressions associated with Christianity but becoming a Christian individually is very different to joining a religious group.

Christianity, at its root, is personal. You either believe or you don’t. It isn’t difficult to become a Christian but no one becomes a Christian on someone else’s behalf. It’s a choice each person makes. Religion does not serve as an intermediary. The church cannot save. No individual or institution can mediate this experience for anyone else.

Religion’s only job is to spread the word. Anything beyond that is indulgence.

Becoming a Christian is a personal decision that involves no ceremonies. Institutional membership is a completely separate decision. And confessions afterward do nothing to cure or remove the root from which all sinful behavior stems. Ceremony and membership have no part in conversion at all.

Even inside a single household this holds: children raised in a Christian home under Christian practices still decide, individually, whether they believe or not. Institutions can surround that decision. They can’t make it.

This matters because Christianity does have a religious expression — the same way a marriage has a legal expression in a certificate. But the certificate isn’t the marriage, and the institution isn’t the faith. Once religion starts standing in for Christianity rather than simply organizing its practice, something has gone wrong.

What the Bible Actually Says About Religion

It’s worth noting that the word “religion” is barely a biblical term at all. It isn’t used in the Old Testament. The word, as we use it today — to refer to a formal system of belief and practice — wasn’t even coined until roughly the first century BCE in writings outside the Bible entirely. When the word finally shows up in the New Testament, it’s almost never used approvingly.

The word encompasses a wide range of practices and attitudes. There is no standard nature for religion. It can be quite gracious or rigid to the point of violence. Based on the historical record, even Christian religions can be destructive and often were.

Paul describes himself before his conversion as belonging to “the strictest sect” of the Pharisees (Acts 26:5) — a devotion so total it drove him to persecute and execute Christians. He uses the word “sect,” not “religion,” but the attitude he displayed is the same one commonly displayed in religion: certainty hardening into cruelty.

Religion complicates what grace made simple. Colossians 2 warns against exactly this — a thicket of rules (“don’t touch, don’t taste, don’t handle”) standing in for the far simpler thing the Bible actually asks of believers.

Religion can become about appearances. Matthew 23 records the words of Jesus as He describes the most demanding religious group of His day, the Pharisees. He doesn’t use the word “religion,” but He describes precisely what religious practice tends to decay into: Performance before the community rather than substance before God.

None of this means the concept is irrelevant to the Bible — it’s addressed directly enough. But it’s addressed almost entirely as a corrective, not an endorsement.

The only reference that puts religion in perspective is found in James 1:27 which says:

Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this: To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction and to keep oneself unspotted from the world.

The biblical writer doesn’t take the time to analyze every religion or talk about all the things religion can do. Instead he focuses on the activities at the core of what he refers to a “pure” religion, a reference that suggests religion can be quite impure. In other words, religion has the potential to be just as wrong as it does to be right.

Orphans and widows in the New Testament period were society’s most vulnerable. Looking after them was religion’s primary focus. Staying unspotted was also important but I’m sure orphans and widows wouldn’t refuse help from the less savory.

The Old Testament ceremonial law makes the point from a different angle: it was there to teach a truth, and once the truth landed — once grace arrived — the ceremony was no longer needed. Once we discovered why pork was disallowed and how we can avoid its toxic effect, the prohibitions no longer applied.

Old Testament law also allowed for generosity. Every third year the tithe was dropped off at local collections spots and the poor were allowed to help themselves to whatever they needed.

The restrictions – which is where the religious often reside – weren’t sticky, the meaning was.

Jewish communities still provide material support to those in their community who struggle to get financial traction. Unfortunately, they don’t offer this for anyone outside their community and other religions haven’t adopted the mindset either.

But Isn’t Christianity Just Another Religion

At this point, the obvious objection: Doesn’t Christianity share the basic shape of every religion — a belief that can’t be proven, a philosophical case for that belief, a real choice to join? Yes. On that framework, Christianity qualifies as a religion like any other.

But sharing a structure isn’t the same as sharing a nature. Two buildings can both be “structures” and still be nothing alike. The real question isn’t whether Christianity looks like religion — it’s whether religion has, in practice, replaced what Christianity was supposed to be.

Has religion – the wrong religion, the misaligned religion – taken over?

One comparison across religions actually makes the point. Christians, Muslims, and Jews claim to worship the same God — the God of Abraham — yet the nature of the god each represents is entirely different based on how they act toward each other, toward the people in their own communities, and, yes, toward those who don’t participate at all.

It isn’t unusual to find adherents in each of these traditions who hate and fight with those in the other two.

Confusing the situation even more, Hindus hold to a multitude of gods – so many they can’t be counted, and Buddhists hold to none. There is nothing standardized about religion, which is exactly why lumping Christianity in with “religion in general” flattens a distinction that matters.

Institutionalized Religion’s Effect: Divide And Coerce

This is where the point from the opening section comes back into focus. The most divided religion of all is the Christian version. And worse, it’s also the most imposing. Christians are commanded to evangelize, meaning spread the word about Christ and salvation.

But that message (the Gospel) is to be offered, not forced. And legalisms have no part in the Gospel

When people of any religion can’t defend their unprovable claims persuasively, the common response is obsession not humility, and eventually coercion. European history is full of examples. The religious – meaning mostly the Catholics – required communities to submit to baptism and the teachings of the church on pain of death.

That definitely describes religion but it has no connection to Christianity. Get baptized or die! Where’s the faith in that approach.

That pattern shows up across religious traditions generally. It’s the pattern Christianity is meant to resist, not repeat.

Jesus prayed for one thing above almost everything else for his followers: that they would be unified (John 17). “Denomination” — a word that doesn’t appear anywhere in the Bible — is the opposite of what His prayer requested. Jesus wasn’t asking us to agree on every detail. He was suggesting that we respect each other in spite of the differences.

“Denomination” isn’t a neutral organizational term. It’s a public declaration of division, and by now there are enough Christian denominations (an estimated 45,000, according to researchers at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary) that division has become the defining feature, not an unfortunate side effect.

When you add aggression to division the potential for injury and hurt is huge.

That fracturing isn’t abstract. It has produced real bloodshed in the past – lots of it – and estrangement in the present — families and neighborhoods split by disagreements. Donald Trump has used that division to great effect.

All these observations raise an uncomfortable question: If Jesus’s prayer for unity was inspired scripture, preserved so believers would hear it, why has it gone so thoroughly unanswered? The likeliest answer isn’t that the prayer failed. It’s that the people who heard it didn’t take it to heart.

There is no one more disobedient than a religious person who thinks their idea is the only idea and everyone must live by the same rule.

All of this helps you realize that the answer to some prayers, maybe most prayers, requires a human response. God is willing for Christians to be unified. Jesus is willing for Christians to be unified but unity will never happen without a human response.

And we for sure aren’t aiming at unity among all Christians when prominent Christians are attempting to align the government with one set of rules.

This tendency to denominationalize is where religion’s instinct toward force comes from. When believers can’t fully prove what they believe — and they can’t, since religious claims are matters of faith, not hard evidence — the frustration of failing to persuade someone can curdle into an urge to require belief instead of invite it.

That is, in practice, exactly what a religious state looks like: agreement enforced by law rather than earned by argument. A Christian Nationalist government, whichever denomination ends up writing the rules, would be exactly this — not Christian humility extended into government, but religion doing what religion tends to do when it gets institutional power.

Christians are called to defend their convictions, not weaponize them. Persuasion, not coercion. Argument, not demand. Somewhere along the way, defense became offense, and offense became politics.

Religion Isn’t Measured by the Religious. It’s Measured by What They Do for Others

Religion involves two important elements: teaching and doing.

And there are two sides to what religion teaches. One side involves things that aren’t easily understood: the trinity, creation, salvation and the very existence of God. These ideas are accepted by faith and that’s the way it’s supposed to be.

Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. (Hebrews 11:1)

And

Without faith it is impossible to please God. (Hebrews 11:6)

Religion involves a set of ideas but it’s much more than ideology. What you believe determines what you do, how you think, the attitudes you entertain, and the way you respond to the culture around you. In other words, beliefs motivate actions.

How a person acts is directly related to what they believe is true.

One attitude commonly found in religious circles is:

I don’t act like you, and because of that I’m better than you. To make things better, I’m going to make laws that force you to mirror my actions.

That really misses the point. Apart from the fact that no one person’s idea are to be imposed on everyone else, religion was never meant to be a self-improvement program, and evaluating it that way — is this person good, consistent, sincere — misses what actually matters. Religion’s value isn’t measured by the state of its adherents. It’s measured by what it produces for the people around them.

I’m not saying that individuals can’t be qualified as good or bad depending on their actions. I’m saying that religion, which is not a person, is measured by the attitudes it harbors toward others and the help it extends to the most vulnerable.

By that standard, religion’s record is genuinely mixed, and honesty requires holding both halves at once. It has pulled people out of addiction, out of destructive patterns, out of isolation — the same function a support community like Alcoholics Anonymous serves, reinforcing resolve in people who need reinforcement. That’s real, and it matters.

But the same institutional force that builds that kind of community is also the force behind division, coercion, and no small share of history’s worst atrocities. Both of those outcomes emanate from the same root: religion is a human institution built around unprovable belief, and human institutions amplify whatever is put into them — generosity or certainty, humility or control.

The measure, then, isn’t how devout someone appears, or how firmly they hold their doctrine, or how many people agree with them. It’s simpler and harder than that: Does this institution, in practice, make the people it touches — believers and outsiders alike — better off? Christianity, at its root, was never supposed to need the question answered by force. It was supposed to answer it by example.

What is commonly referred to as “Christian” Nationalism – which no one can really define – should more accurately be called “Religious” Nationalism and that’s not a good thing.

THINBK!AboutIt

Share this:

  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Tweet

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Filed Under: Catholicism, Charity, Christian Living, Religion

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Faith Tees
Calvinism's Fallacies: Why The Gospel Applies To Anyone, Anywhere, At Any Time, Under Any Circumstance
In Defense of Divorce
This book doesn't say what you've already heard.

SUBSCRIBE

Recent Posts

  • “Christian” Is Biblical – “Religion” Not So Much
  • Same-Sex Marriage: Allowed Or Not
  • Everyone Needs Repentance, Even Christians
  • What Is The Meaning Of Baptism
  • Why It’s Impossible To Invoke Old Testament Law In The Modern Era

Copyright © 2026 · Dynamik-Gen on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

%d